YNN.com

Albany / Schenectady / Troy

Change region

  34º

Updated 04/21/2009 10:26 AM

Battle for the 20th continues

By: Curtis Schick

Battle for the 20th continues
CAPITAL REGION, N.Y. -- There was no major ruling Monday in Dutchess County, but Democrats there think the writing is on the wall for Jim Tedisco.

“I think it is pretty clear the numbers are not in his favor,” said Henry Berger, a lawyer for Scott Murphy.

And in elections, you better believe it is all about the numbers. Right now, Democrat Scott Murphy leads Republican Jim Tedisco by nearly 300 votes.

In front of Dutchess County Courthouse, Berger said it might be time for Tedisco to throw in the towel.

  To view our videos, you need to
enable JavaScript. Learn how.
install Adobe Flash 9 or above. Install now.

Then come back here and refresh the page.

“If they stop counting he loses and based on the number of challenges, he's out challenged us two to one. So if we continue to count, he loses,” Berger said.

“We are talking about 200 votes separating the parties and by some counts over 1,800 absentee ballots. Numerically, that's awful lot of ballots to be counted,” said James Walsh, a campaign lawyer for Jim Tedisco.

In Saratoga County, where Tedisco won, the challenges are about 50-50. But Berger says Republican objections in counties were Murphy won outnumber Democratic challenges in those places overwhelmingly. For example, in Columbia County, Democrats objected to a few dozen. Republicans challenged a few hundred ballots. Berger believes a good chunk of those will come back. But Walsh says a lot of those votes were made by people who don't live in the district and shouldn't count.

“My client has instructed me to make sure every valid ballot is counted and that is what I am carrying out,” said Walsh.

And even with Judge James Brands allowed Republicans to reargue last week's order that disallowed challenges based on ballot applications, some in Tedisco's party say this race is already over.

Former National Republican Congressional Committee Chairman Tom Davis told the Washington Times Sunday, "We lost the special election in New York. It's gone."

The only order from Judge James Brands on Monday was that he wants all objected to ballots delivered to the State Board of Elections by Thursday.